As to the tragic altercation between 杨振宁 and 李政道, it is undoubted that 杨振宁 is the one much more culpable. Ever since, 李政道 was coerced to respond passively only when it was very necessary.
The tenacious contention is really peculiar, childish and consequential. It astounded and confounded the whole world. They perpetuated the senseless argument to the vast detriment of their own prestige. It costed 杨振宁先生 of at least one more Nobel Prize. It is embarrassing to many Chinese scholars around the world.
However, as a matter of fact, the altercation was neither illegal nor immoral, and did no harm to the world. They are the sole victims of themselves. That controversy is far from an ethical blemish on either of them.
Therefore, 杨振宁先生 is NOT a good role model in ethics, while he is a great role model in physics.
ft 发表评论于 2025-10-27 08:31:57
不会英文的人也能贴出大段大段完美的英文跟帖，现成的工具抓来就可用，分分钟的事。
ft 发表评论于 2025-10-27 08:29:10
不会写中文吗
ft 发表评论于 2025-10-27 08:27:31
不会学中文吗？！
ft 发表评论于 2025-10-27 08:26:10
辩不过就不要东拉西扯。拿出证据服人。
诚信 发表评论于 2025-10-27 08:20:59
Why do Trump loyalists also hate 杨振宁?
Is it because of their illiteracy and ignorance, or partisan affiliations such as some cult or Taiwan separationist?
诺贝尔奖评审档案（Ref.NP-1957-12）
1994年解密记录：诺贝尔评委会内部文件
显示，李政道被认定为"首个提出可验证宇称不守恒方案的研究者”，而杨振宁的贡献被标注为“后续数学辅助工作”。评委会主席
Oskar Klein在1957年会议记录中写道："李
的原始构想是实验设计的唯一基础（原
*"Lee's original scheme was the sole foundation of the experiment.")
《20世纪物理学史》（剑桥大学出版2018）
"李政道1956年4月至5月初的手稿与实验方案，已完整独立地构建了宇称不守恒的理论框架。杨振宁的介入始于5月中旬，其修改仅限于符最规范化与数学表达优化（如群论统步动，宋融及核心思想”。
哥伦比亚大学档案馆藏编号LC-2012-003
李政道原始手稿亲笔推导的宇称不守恒方程，署期1956年5月8日。手稿已包含T-G谜题的非对称解、弱相互作用中宇称破缺的数学证明，核心思想完整。
The absence of 习近平 and his proteges from the funeral of 杨振宁先生 reflects the fact that 杨振宁先生 had never fawned on nor bowed to the communist regime. This in turn implies that he went to China for the purpose of serving the country, instead of the regime or his own interests. He must have expressed some opinions or even criticisms that antagonized 习近平 who is ignorant yet arrogant, and fond of pointing out the direction for everything.
Even worse, the excessive ignorance of 习近平 culminates in his distain and aversion to prominent intellectuals, especially 杨振宁先生 who is commonly revered as the most preeminent Chinese scientist worldwide in modern era. His attitude eventually hindered communist officials at all ranks from attending the funeral.
诚信 发表评论于 2025-10-27 03:07:41
1. Above all, 杨振宁 has never done anything harmful to the world or anybody else.
2. 杨振宁 is a great role model in physics, but not a good role model in ethics.
3. All criticisms and malice toward 杨振宁 actually stem from ignorance about him. For examples,
(1) "在李政道面前，杨振宁是沽名钓誉的小人。在邓稼先面前，杨振宁是唯利是图的小人。"
In fact, without the collaboration with 杨振宁, 李政道 could not have had chance to be crowned with Nobel prize. It was 杨振宁 who rescued 邓稼先 who was being persecuted and almost executed.
(2) "如果年轻的时候就回国做贡献 就值得称赞"
In early 1950s, thousands of young scientists 回国做贡献. But most of them were persecuted as espionages and many died from the persecutions.
In conclusion, it is ignorance and stupidity that actuate people to criticize 杨振宁, who in fact is a GREAT scientist and a great Chinese.
